Skip to content

What a Reddit Comment Can Reveal Without Its Username

In a test of selected long public Reddit comments, Claude Fable 5.2 matched about 3 in 10 of the comments it answered to the accounts that posted them without being given the usernames.

When Martyna Gliniecka was planning a study of Reddit discussions about young people’s health, she asked users in 3 communities what they thought about researchers using public posts. Some wanted their usernames left out. Young people she consulted said they valued keeping their Reddit activity separate from their offline lives. Gliniecka collected the discussion text without usernames or other details such as timestamps.

Leaving those details out kept the usernames off her copies of the posts. A November preprint asked what an AI model could recover from a different set of public Reddit comments. Without web access or a list of candidate names, Claude Fable 5.2 correctly matched 31.1% of the comments it answered to the account that had posted them. That was a username match, not a search for someone’s offline identity. The experiment didn’t test Gliniecka’s material.

For anyone giving an assistant a set of comments to analyze, there are two decisions here: what to put next to the words, and whether to send the exact words at all. On a copy stripped of usernames, the account is no longer there to read. Sometimes it is still possible to guess it.

Which accounts came back

The researchers chose 1,258 comments from 870 accounts in 32 communities, many with a technical focus. Every comment had at least 200 words after quotations were removed, and the team excluded comments with obvious identifiers or sensitive disclosures. Fable gave an answer for 1,244 comments. The headline rate counts each answered comment equally. When the researchers instead averaged the rates of the 860 accounts with at least one answer, the match rate was 24.1%.

Earlier activity in the same community went with much higher match rates. Fable’s reported rate was 68.9% for comments by accounts with more than 500 contributions there, counting posts and comments from June 2025 through May 2026. It was 12.8% for comments by accounts with 1 to 50. Those groups may differ in what they wrote as well as how often they wrote. The study didn’t measure what the model had seen in training, and those ranges aren’t thresholds for individual risk.

The model could have encountered older material tied to some accounts. That’s different from memorizing the very comments used in the experiment. Another model, Claude Opus 5.5, got about 17% of its answers right on the same sample, even though those comments appeared after its public release. The comments went up before Fable’s release but after its reported knowledge cutoff, which is a weaker check against memorization. Neither comparison tells us which matches depended on subject matter, phrasing or something else.

Most of Fable’s answers didn’t match the original account. In 5 runs on the same material, the overall rates stayed close, but Fable didn’t always return the same answer for a given comment. The researchers could compare the guesses with the original usernames. A guess on an unsigned passage doesn’t come with that check. It isn’t evidence enough to attach a name to the passage.

Who needs the exact words?

Reddit already makes a distinction between hiding a label or a listing and restricting who can see the words. Users can leave a community’s posts and comments off their profiles. The same material remains visible in the community and can still show up in search. The setting changes where the comments appear, not who can read them there.

A researcher sorting discussions by topic might be able to share a description of each thread instead of the original sentences. If the research is about how people bring up a difficult question, the wording is part of the evidence. Replacing it changes what the next reader can assess. No result here establishes that a summary makes a new collection anonymous. The choice the researcher can make before sharing is narrower: who needs to see this exact sentence?

Sources